SPECIALIST SARS PENALTY SUPPORT

Tax Penalties

SARS penalties can be significant, but not every penalty is challenged in the same way. The first step is to identify the type of penalty, the statutory basis on which it was imposed and the remedy that is actually available.

We assist with administrative non-compliance penalties, percentage-based penalties, reportable-arrangement penalties and understatement penalties.

The penalty percentage is only the end result — the real dispute is often about why the penalty was imposed at all.

At a glance

Different SARS penalties require different legal and procedural responses.

01
Administrative penalties

Fixed-amount penalties can arise from listed non-compliance, including failures to submit required returns.

02
Percentage-based penalties

These can arise where specified tax amounts are paid late or other percentage-based penalty provisions apply.

03
Reportable-arrangement penalties

Failure to meet applicable reportable-arrangement disclosure obligations can attract separate penalties.

04
Understatement penalties

These are linked to an understatement involving a behaviour listed in the statutory penalty table and require a different technical analysis.

Tax Exclusive
SPECIALIST PRACTICE
Penalty Analysis
Statutory Basis
Remission & Disputes
Procedural Strategy
Understatement Focus
Behaviour & Evidence

THE PENALTY

A penalty should be tested against the provision that authorises it.

Penalties are not interchangeable. An administrative non-compliance penalty, a percentage-based penalty and an understatement penalty arise under different provisions and can carry different remission, objection and appeal routes. A proper challenge therefore starts with classification.

The value lies in challenging the correct legal element — not merely asking SARS to reduce the amount.

Administrative non-compliance penalties

These penalties arise under the Tax Administration Act for listed forms of non-compliance. Fixed-amount penalties can recur while the non-compliance continues, and in appropriate cases a request for remission may be available before objection and appeal become relevant.


Percentage-based penalties

Percentage-based penalties generally arise in relation to specified payment or tax-compliance failures. The underlying tax type, timing and statutory provision determine both the penalty and the possible remission route.


Understatement penalties

Understatement penalties require a different enquiry. Under the post-1 April 2026 framework, the penalty regime applies where an understatement involves a behaviour listed in the section 223 table. The particular behaviour, the evidence supporting SARS’s classification and any statutory remission ground must therefore be analysed carefully.


We can assist with

  • Reviewing the legal basis and calculation of SARS penalties.
  • Requests for remission of qualifying administrative penalties.
  • Objections and appeals where a penalty or remission decision is challengeable.
  • Understatement-penalty behaviour classifications and supporting evidence.
  • Penalty issues arising from SARS audits and additional assessments.
  • Reportable-arrangement and other material penalty disputes.

How we approach it

From penalty assessment to a focused challenge.

We first identify the penalty and statutory route, then test the facts, evidence and procedural remedy that apply to that penalty.


01

Classify
The Penalty

We identify the penalty type, legal provision, assessment or decision and the relevant procedural deadline.

02

Test
The Basis

We examine the non-compliance, understatement, behaviour classification or payment failure SARS relies on.

03

Build
The Evidence

We gather the facts and documents relevant to remission, reasonable grounds, behaviour or other statutory requirements.

04

Pursue
The Remedy

We use the appropriate remission, objection, appeal or dispute process rather than treating every penalty challenge the same way.

Strategic considerations

What can materially affect the penalty outcome.

Penalty disputes are often won or lost on classification, timing and evidence rather than on the size of the penalty alone.

Understatement penalties should be addressed as early as possible.

SARS will often raise the proposed penalty behaviour during or immediately after an audit. That is an important stage to address factual assumptions, the taxpayer’s conduct and the legal basis for the proposed classification before the assessment is finalised.

Understatement penalty
Audit stage
Behaviour

The 2026 understatement-penalty framework changed the sequence of the enquiry.

From 1 April 2026, the legislation requires attention first to whether the understatement involves a listed behaviour. Bona fide inadvertent error is no longer the general gateway exclusion it was under the prior wording and now remains relevant in the statutory remission context for substantial understatement.

1 April 2026
Section 222
Section 223

A professional tax opinion can matter, but only if the statutory requirements are satisfied.

For substantial understatement, the legislation contains a specific opinion-based remission route. Timing, independence of the registered tax practitioner, full disclosure of the relevant facts and the conclusion reached in the opinion all matter.

Professional opinion
Substantial understatement

Correcting the underlying non-compliance can be urgent.

Some administrative penalties can recur while the default continues. The taxpayer may therefore need to remedy the underlying non-compliance even while separately pursuing remission or disputing the penalty.

Administrative penalty
Recurring penalty

Frequently asked questions

Important things to know

The main categories include administrative non-compliance penalties, percentage-based penalties, reportable-arrangement penalties and understatement penalties. The legal test and remedy differ depending on the penalty involved.

Some penalties can be remitted in whole or in part where the statutory requirements are met. The relevant grounds depend on the penalty type, and for administrative penalties a request for remission is generally the first formal step before objection and appeal.

The amended framework now requires the understatement to involve a behaviour listed in the section 223 table before the penalty is imposed. The former broad bona fide inadvertent error gateway was removed, while bona fide inadvertent error remains relevant as a statutory remission ground for substantial understatement.

Potentially, particularly in relation to the statutory remission route for substantial understatement. The opinion must meet the specific legislative requirements, including requirements concerning timing, independence, disclosure of facts and the conclusion reached.

As early as possible where the amount is material, the penalty follows an audit, SARS alleges serious behaviour, or there is a dispute about the legal basis for the penalty. Early intervention can help ensure that the evidentiary and procedural position is properly preserved.

CONFIDENTIAL PENALTY DISCUSSION

Has SARS imposed a penalty that you believe should be challenged?

We can review the penalty, the statutory basis on which it was imposed and the surrounding facts and help determine whether remission or dispute remedies are available. We will confirm scope and fees before any work commences.