Company EG & Company LS v CSARS
Overview
This training session examines the Tax Court judgment in IT 77406 & IT 77357, concerning the income tax treatment of rental income derived by commercial share block companies.
The session explores whether rental income accrued to the companies or their shareholders for purposes of the definition of “gross income”, the application of the share block company exemption under section 10(1)(e) of the Income Tax Act, and the significance of the companies’ contractual arrangements, financial records and practical operation of the share block schemes. It further considers the distinction between a SARS verification and audit, the limits of the Tax Court’s jurisdiction in relation to procedural review grounds, the contra fiscum rule, and the restrictions on introducing new grounds during the tax dispute process.
The judgment provides important guidance on the relationship between legal form, contractual rights, accounting treatment and the actual implementation of arrangements when determining the correct tax consequences.
Notes
Download publication
Download notes

